Karzai Takes Lead in Afghan Vote as Count Shows Lower Turnout
Aug. 26 (Bloomberg) -- Afghanistan’s Independent ElectionCommission announced a lead of 2 percentage points for PresidentHamid Karzai over his rival, Abdullah Abdullah, as the firstvotes were counted from the Aug. 20 presidential election.
Karzai has 38 percent of the ballots counted so far, to 36percent for Abdullah, his former foreign minister, said ChiefElectoral Officer Daoud Ali Najafi at a press conference inKabul yesterday. The returns represent 550,000 votes from 10percent of the polling stations.
Najafi said in an interview the votes “are very balanced”between Karzai’s strongholds in the south and Abdullah’s in thenorth. He didn’t announce the geographic breakdown.
The figures gave the first indication of the turnout, whichat 5.5 million would be about 30 percent less than inAfghanistan’s first direct presidential election, in 2004.
Reduced voter participation, plus more than 400 fraudreports filed with the United Nations-backed ElectoralComplaints Commission, may undercut the credibility of anelection the Obama administration hopes will politicallystrengthen the Afghan government for battle against TalibanIslamic militants.
Abdullah renewed his declaration that Karzai’s campaigntried to steal the election, which the president’s team denies.In the garden of his home, Abdullah showed reporters a video ofmen stuffing ballot boxes and a sheaf of ballot papers markedfor Karzai that he said his supporters had recovered from anoperation by the president’s campaign.
Fraud Opportunities Increased
Independent election monitoring teams from the Washington-based National Democratic Institute and the Free and FairElection Foundation of Afghanistan say opportunities for fraudwere increased in last week’s vote because Taliban influenceover many rural areas kept independent observers, as well asvoters, away from polling places.
The election commission’s portrayal of a close racecontrasted with Finance Minister Hazrat Omar Zakhilwal’sassertion to reporters Aug. 24 that a nearly complete vote countprovided to the cabinet shows Karzai winning with 68 percent.Karzai’s campaign office backed away from that claim.
With Karzai having lost popularity since winning 55 percentof votes in 2004, such a landslide “is far beyond theexpectation of Afghans,” and “if it were announced officiallyit would be a shock,” said Waliullah Rahmani, director of theKabul Center for Strategic Studies, a pro-democracy researchgroup. Two opinion surveys conducted last month by U.S.-basedresearch groups indicated he would get 40 percent to 44 percentof the vote.
Compromise Debated
The high-level declaration of a Karzai landslide “may bemeant to put pressure on other candidates to reach a politicalcompromise,” said Haroun Mir, director of Afghanistan’s Centerfor Research & Policy Studies, an independent think tank.
Abdullah argued against any political deal that mightdisguise electoral fraud. Addressing Afghans in his pressconference, he said he wouldn’t “compromise your rights inexchange for anything,” or “turn a blind eye to the big statemockery.”
Over eight years, Karzai and his international backers, ledby the U.S., have failed to keep Afghanistan’s war fromspreading or to improve the lives of most of its people.Measured by income, life expectancy and literacy, Afghanistan isthe world’s fifth-poorest country, according to a 2007 report bythe Afghan government and the UN.
Complaints Commission
Abdullah says he has faith in the neutrality of the five-member Electoral Complaints Commission, which has three membersappointed by the office of the UN secretary-general. Thecommission was formed four months ago to adjudicate electiondisputes and has had little time to prepare, said AurelieDemauge-Bost, a legal analyst with the European Union’s electionobserver team in Kabul.
At least 35 fraud complaints are “material to theoutcome” of the election, according to Grant Kippen, thecomplaints commission’s Canadian chairman. His agency can orderrecounts or a repeat of voting where it finds fraud, and thevote results will be declared final only after all fraudcomplaints have been investigated.
Karzai has said he would win with the absolute majority ofvotes required to avoid a runoff. While some independentelection monitors say a runoff might buttress the perceivedlegitimacy of the vote by demonstrating that it was competitive,a second round might be risky, Mir said in a phone interview.
“The low turnout in the south last week, and the Taliban’sability to attack voters, means that no one there will vote in asecond round,” he said.
To contact the reporter on this story:James Rupert in Kabul at jrupert3@ bloomberg.net.
Last Updated: August 25, 2009 17:05 EDTSource: Bloomberg
« Back to World News
Related News
-
UN Mission Split Over How to Deal With Afghan Election Fraud Aug 25, 2009 @ 03:39 PM
Sept. 16 (Bloomberg) -- The United Nations says its missionin Afghanistan is split over how many votes should be recountedafter allegations of widespread fraud in last month’s elections,with a top UN official leaving the country over the dispute.
-
Afghanistan looking for way forward after election Aug 25, 2009 @ 03:39 PM
KABUL — Afghanistan's electoral officials searched for a way Monday to salvage an election marred by reports of ballot stuffing and phantom voters, mulling how much of the vote to throw out because of fraud.
-
Karzai Leads in Afghan Vote; Count Shows Low Turnout Aug 25, 2009 @ 03:39 PM
Aug. 26 (Bloomberg) -- Hamid Karzai held a narrow lead inearly returns from Afghanistan’s presidential election, raisingthe prospect of a run-off vote that might provoke furtherattacks and intimidation by Taliban militants.
-
Karzai leading in Afghan voter survey Aug 25, 2009 @ 03:39 PM
KABUL — A U.S. government-funded survey of Afghan voters released Monday shows President Hamid Karzai with a substantial lead just 10 days before the country's presidential election, but still short of the support needed to avoid a run-off.
-
Taliban threaten Afghan voters in November runoff Aug 25, 2009 @ 03:39 PM
KABUL — Taliban militants threatened Afghans with violence Saturday if they vote in the Nov. 7 runoff presidential election, as President Hamid Karzai's campaign ruled out any power-sharing deal to avoid another ballot.
